Staten Island Web logo

Johnny C Connelly mcgil The best ice cream cake ever made! The Sedutto's store is still in the same place on New Dorp Lane. I don't know if it's owned by the same family, but it's still there.

At one point, in the late 70's, Sedutto's was bought by the Sara Lee company. They expanded until there were Sedutto stores all over the city and Sedutto's was the "in" ice cream. Apparently, they expanded too much, too fast, only to become very unprofitable for Sara Lee. The stores in the city were closed and they sold the company back to either the family or the employees. That was in the mid- to late 80's. I don't know what happened after that or who owns the name now, but as I said earlier, they're still on New Dorp Lane. And I'd give anything for a piece of their ice cream cake right now.


Staten Island WebŪ Forums Index.